top of page

A Closer Look into the Protect College Sports Act

Writer: Louissa Lynn
Louissa Lynn
Nov 6
5 min read

Photo Credit: NCAA


The Protect College Sports Act promises to stabilize college athletics by establishing national rules for athlete compensation, transfers and eligibility. But creating a clearer system also raises questions about who controls that system and how athletes can hold schools accountable.


Led by Sens. Ted Cruz and Maria Cantwell, the legislation passed the Senate by a bipartisan vote of 77–22 on Sept. 28, sending it to the House of Representatives for consideration. Supporters argue that a national framework would help address conflicting state laws, ongoing litigation and growing financial pressures across college sports.


The proposal combines new athlete protections with stronger authority to enforce restrictions on compensation and player movement. Understanding that balance is central to understanding the bill.


What changes for athletes?


The bill would establish federal name, image and likeness (NIL) rights and cap agent fees at 5%. It also includes scholarship protections and requirements for sports-related medical coverage. Supporters present these measures as a way to make athlete rights more consistent across schools and states.


Athletes could transfer once between four-year schools without losing eligibility. A second transfer would generally require sitting out an academic year, with exceptions if their sport is discontinued, their head coach leaves, they experience sexual assault or harassment by someone associated with their institution, or they pursue a graduate degree.


For schools, these restrictions could make roster planning more predictable. For athletes, they would place conditions on moving between programs while preserving flexibility in specified circumstances. It brings back a most consistent roster for all involved, rather than chasing NIL money, or perceived better benefits season to season.


Another notable adjustment is section 205 of the bill. This section restricts certain mergers and acquisitions involving football-centered conferences reporting more than $700 million in annual revenue. For certain acquisitions involving schools outside the bill’s protected group, expansion would be permitted only if the resulting conference had no more than 20 members. These provisions would constrain consolidation without imposing a blanket ban on conference realignment.


How would spending work?


The legislation would allow schools to exceed the revenue-sharing cap through a $22.5 million retention fund for athletes who have completed at least one full competitive season at their institution. Schools could also qualify for up to $5 million in additional spending tied to compensation for non-revenue sports, including women’s and Olympic sports. These allowances would expand permitted spending without guaranteeing athletes a payment.


Separately, schools with at least $80 million in annual athletics revenue would generally have to preserve their total scholarship opportunities and roster spots across non-revenue sports at 2024–25 levels. The requirement would preserve overall scholarship opportunities and roster spots across these sports, but would not guarantee the survival of every individual team. Schools could also seek waivers under specified circumstances.


The retention fund could make staying at a school more financially attractive. However, permission to spend more does not mean every athletic department could afford to do so. A common spending framework would still leave schools making different decisions based on their resources.


The bill would also prevent schools and affiliated groups, such as collectives, from bypassing the revenue-sharing cap by routing payments through third parties. This would help ensure that the cap limits spending rather than simply changing where the money comes from.


Protections beyond a playing career


The legislation would require coverage of qualifying sports-related out-of-pocket medical expenses during participation and for five years after an eligible athlete’s last college competition.


It would also allow qualifying former Division I athletes to return to complete an undergraduate degree within a 10-year window following their final eligibility year. Financial assistance would generally reflect their previous scholarship amount, with need-based aid recalculated according to current circumstances. The provision would not automatically guarantee a full scholarship.


These protections could matter well beyond the athletes receiving major endorsement deals. An unfinished degree or a lasting sports injury can affect an athlete long after their final game. Still, the existence of protections does not settle the debate over whether they go far enough.


Speaking remotely to a University of Michigan sport management class on October 9th, 2026, Sen. Richard Blumenthal explained why he opposed the legislation despite supporting federal reform.


“And I felt that there were insufficient guarantees for the athletes on education and on health care in this bill,” he said.


Blumenthal’s objection was not that the bill lacked education or health care provisions. He questioned whether those guarantees were strong enough and whether athletes could realistically enforce them against their own schools. 



Who enforces the protections?


The NCAA strongly supports the legislation because it would provide a firmer legal foundation for enforcing compensation, transfer and eligibility rules. The organization argues that national standards would bring stability to schools and athletes. That approach also raises a central question: how much authority should governing bodies gain to restrict athlete opportunities in exchange for the protections the bill provides?


Blumenthal questioned whether stronger enforcement authority would serve athletes’ interests when the NCAA remains closely aligned with powerful schools. While acknowledging improvements in its leadership, he said the organization remains “an agent of the schools,” particularly “the more powerful schools, the more wealthy schools.” His criticism raises questions about whose interests would guide the enforcement of the bill’s new rules.


The bill would allow athletes to sue over specified violations, including those involving scholarships, medical coverage, and health and safety standards. It also provides targeted antitrust protection for enforcing covered rules on matters such as compensation, transfers, and eligibility.


These provisions address different concerns: giving athletes a way to challenge violations while giving governing bodies greater legal certainty to enforce the rules. Blumenthal questioned whether athletes could realistically use those remedies against the institutions overseeing their education, playing careers, and often scholarships. 


“This bill puts the burden of enforcement on the athletes,” he said.


He argued that athletes may lack the resources or willingness to sue their own schools. His proposed alternative was to give state attorneys general and the Federal Trade Commission enforcement authority.


“Obviously, I would have given state attorneys general and the FTC enforcement authority so they could have taken action not only against schools or agents that violated law but also against the NCAA if necessary,” he said.


That distinction is important. The disagreement is not simply about whether protections exist, but whether athletes have a practical way to enforce them.


The Big Ten moves ahead


The Big Ten is already preparing for the legislation’s financial framework. On Oct. 28, the conference announced an immediately effective rule limiting each school’s involvement in arranging third-party NIL agreements to $27.5 million. Combined with permitted direct payments, the rule establishes an approximately $49 million framework per institution.


The policy applies to institutional involvement. Athletes remain free to pursue NIL opportunities independently, subject to existing rules. It is therefore not a blanket cap on everything a school’s athletes can earn.


For Michigan and its conference opponents, the decision brings new constraints to recruiting and roster planning while federal legislation remains under consideration. It also shows why the details of the PCSA matter: schools are already making decisions around the system it proposes.


A clearer financial framework could help athletic departments plan. The larger test is whether that stability comes with protections athletes can actually use.


 As of Nov. 2, the Protect College Sports Act has cleared the Senate but still awaits House approval. Its proposed protections and restrictions are therefore not yet federal law. The next step is House consideration, with any changes requiring further agreement from the Senate before the legislation can reach the president. 


“So this brave new world of college sports that is ushered in by this bill has more unknowns than certainties,” Blumenthal concluded. 


Comments


bottom of page