top of page

The Value of an Athlete's Social Media Following

Max Adox
Nov 6
3 min read

Photo Credit: The Pulse


Athletes have been a huge weapon in companies’ social media marketing playbook for some time now. Nielsen, a leader in sponsorship and brand analytics, found that 78% of sports fans are more likely to purchase a product if it was endorsed by their favorite athlete. People have a special relationship with sports teams, but individual athletes tend to be more dynamic in their ability to tell stories through a partnership than a team or organization. Plenty of basic factors, like follower count and on-field performance, have always been accounted for when determining the monetary value of an athlete’s social media presence. With the huge amounts of money being poured into social media marketing, brands are becoming more strategic with where they spend their dollars. 


Analytics have always played a role in partnerships between brands and celebrities. For a while, Q scores, which combine familiarity and likability to produce one percentage, were the metric of choice. They gave companies an idea of roughly how popular someone was, but they only gave a small snapshot of how well a particular campaign performed. Now, in the age of social media, as University of Michigan NIL Executive General Manager Terése Whitehead said in an interview, “The number of followers says how popular you are. It’s like the new Q score.” Another similarity between Q scores and follower count is that they both just scratch the surface: "How many people are following you doesn’t necessarily translate into the value of impressions and engagement,” says Whitehead. More than ever, data and algorithms are vital in determining which athletes are the right investment, because they aren’t all created equal. An athlete with 8,000 followers might be more valuable to a brand than one with 15,000 because of potential differences in the rate at which those followers interact with the post beyond a simple view. A strong relationship between a creator and their followers typically raises engagement rates, as followers tend to trust the creator more. 


Another consideration a brand needs to make is market size. While larger cities generally have the most lucrative partnerships available, they also come with the most competition. If you were to take a player getting limited minutes in the California Bay Area, for example, they would be competing against athletes from the 49ers, Warriors, Valkyries, etc. The still relatively new fact that college athletes can get paid has opened up new opportunities for brands because college athletes, Whitehead says, are a “new way to generate more eyeballs as well as build an affinity with your consumer base.” The competition in large cities opens the door for players in smaller markets across the country. Whitehead said that where a brand ultimately decides to go and whom they decide to partner with comes down to two questions: “Who are we trying to reach? And what story are we trying to tell?”


Every brand’s answer to those questions will be different, but they should all start in the same place: authenticity. “You want to make sure that there's that authenticity factor because that's what creates the conversion to sales,” said Danielle Davison, University of Michigan’s Assistant Athletic Director for NIL. To find that authentic partnership between brand and athlete, you have to look beyond the pure analytics. That goes for both brands and the athletes working with them. A company that hands out money to any old athlete isn’t going to see as much success as one that deliberately targets them based on their alignment with the brand and product. A promotion with an athlete for something they never use or don’t like could very well underperform their usual social media metrics. Conversely, a brand could see higher than expected return on a partnership where the athlete clearly enjoys using the product. “Those are things that these ‘objective’ numbers are missing,” said Davison in an interview, “They are important just to give a baseline of ‘here’s how I can stack up to similar athletes to me,’ but they don’t tell the full story.” 


Even with the abundance of statistics available to companies, doing your homework on the best fit for your unique circumstance is still crucial to the campaign’s success. 

Comments


bottom of page