The Price of Winning: Inside Manchester City’s Fight Over Financial Rules


Photo Credit: Oberlin Review
For more than a decade, Manchester City’s rise has transformed English soccer. Since the club was purchased by the Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG) in 2008, City has developed into one of the Premier League’s dominant forces, winning eight league titles under its current ownership.
Despite its success on the field, the financial practices behind Manchester City’s rise have become the focus of one of the most consequential legal disputes in the history of English soccer.
In September 2026, an independent Premier League commission found Manchester City guilty of all charges relating to breaches of the league’s financial rules spanning a nine season period, from the 2009/10 to 2017/18 seasons. The club was also found guilty of failing to cooperate with the league’s investigation. The decision followed years of investigation and a 42-day hearing that concluded in December 2024. Manchester City continues to deny any wrongdoing and has appealed the commission’s decision, meaning the case and any potential punishment are far from over.
What Manchester City Was Accused Of
At the center of the case is the allegation that Manchester City presented a misleading picture of its finances. According to the independent commission’s findings, City arranged “sham” commercial agreements that allowed the club to report significantly more sponsorship revenue than its commercial partners were actually providing. The commission found that additional money was instead being supplied by Abu Dhabi United Group, the club’s owner, through what it described as a “disguised funding scheme."
The Guardian reported that the scheme amounted to approximately £830.6 million and hid roughly £70 million in additional costs over the nine seasons. Altogether, the arrangements were found to have artificially inflated revenues and reduced expenses by more than £900 million.
These distinctions matter because financial regulations restrict how much clubs can spend. If money supplied by an owner is recorded as independent sponsorship income, a club can appear financially stronger than it really is. The commission found that, had the agreements been reported accurately, City would have been in breach of both Premier League and UEFA spending limits by a very substantial amount.
The commission also found that City filed misstated accounts and concealed its true financial position from auditors and football regulators. This included a “sham” circular agreement with Fordham, a company that bought the club’s players’ image rights. The Guardian also reported that image rights deals involving players and former manager Roberto Mancini were found to be “sham” arrangements.
The Legal Battle
The case has been years in the making. The Premier League began investigating City in December 2018 and issued a complaint in February 2023, referring the case to an independent commission. The hearing lasted 42 days and concluded in December 2024, with the commission’s core decision published almost two years later.
The commission criticized City's conduct during the investigation, finding that the club had made “concerted efforts to stop and frustrate" the league’s investigation. According to the Guardian, it also said that evidence given by a number of important City witnesses was “false in a number of key aspects."
City strongly disputes those conclusions. The club said it was “disappointed and surprised” by the decision and has maintained that evidence supports its position.
On October 2, 2026, the Premier League confirmed that City had formally appealed.
In its appeal, the club is expected to argue that the payments came from the UAE government as a shareholder in the sponsors, not from its owners, according to BBC Sports. The appeal will be considered by a three person Appeal Board, which can uphold the commission’s ruling, overturn it or modify the decision. Until that process is complete, the case, and City’s eventual punishment, remains unresolved.
What Could Happen to Manchester City?
Punishment will be decided separately. The Premier League rules give independent commissions broad authority to impose sanctions, including fines, and point deductions. Reporting surrounding the case has also raised the possibility of transfer restrictions, suspension, or even expulsion from the Premier League. However, expulsion would be complicated, since Premier League clubs would need to approve it with a two-thirds majority vote.
The challenge is that there is little precedent for a case of this size.
Previous financial cases involved dramatically smaller amounts. Everton, for example, received a points deduction following a profitability and sustainability rules violation involving approximately £20 million.
The findings against Manchester City involve financial arrangements totaling hundreds of millions of pounds, making determining a proportionate punishment difficult. A large points deduction could effectively guarantee relegation, while a smaller penalty could be criticized as insufficient given the scale of the violations found by the commission.
The consequences could even extend beyond City.
The Guardian reported that Liverpool, Arsenal, Manchester United, and Tottenham Hotspur lodged formal legal notices reserving their right to seek compensation for losses caused by City’s rule breaches. Rival clubs could claim for lost earnings, titles, or European qualification, though any legal action could only happen after the appeal process is complete.
If those claims move forward, the financial consequences of the case could continue long after the Premier League determines City’s punishment.
A Case Bigger Than One Club
Whatever the outcome of Manchester City’s appeal, the case could reshape how financial rules are enforced across English soccer.
The Premier League now has to determine what meaningful enforcement looks like when violations involve one of its most successful and commercially powerful clubs. The eventual decision could influence how clubs structure sponsorships, report revenue, and approach financial regulations in the future.
For other clubs, the outcome will also signal whether financial rules can maintain a level playing field or whether the advantages gained from breaking them outweigh the consequences. With Manchester City’s appeal still pending, the final decision could set an important precedent for how the Premier League balances financial power, competitive fairness, and accountability for years to come.




Comments